Free shipping across NZ on orders over $150 Shop Offers

Pillow for a Firm Mattress: Getting the Height Right

By Kiwi Wool, makers of alpaca and wool bedding in Mangere, Auckland, since 2002.

On a firm mattress your shoulder and hips sink in less, so your head sits further from the bed when you lie on your side. That means you usually need a higher pillow than you would on a soft mattress to keep your neck straight.

For anyone who has bought a firmer mattress, or sleeps on one, and finds their old pillow no longer feels right.

This is one of the fit guides in our pillow buying guide.

Why the mattress changes the pillow you need

Your pillow fills the gap between your head and the mattress. When a mattress is soft, your body sinks and that gap shrinks. When it is firm, your body stays on top and the gap stays wide. Side sleepers feel this most, because the shoulder is the part that sinks.

MattressSide sleeperBack sleeperStomach sleeper
FirmHigher pillowMedium pillowLow pillow
MediumMedium to highMediumLow
SoftMediumLowerVery low or none

How to check your height on a firm mattress

  1. Lie on your side in your usual position on your own mattress.
  2. Ask someone to look from behind: your head should line up with your spine, not tilt down toward the mattress.
  3. If your head drops, you need more height or a firmer fill. If it tilts up, you need less.
  4. Check again after 20 minutes, once the pillow has settled.

Our pillow height and fit guide has more ways to test it.

Which of our pillows suits a firm mattress

Side sleepers on a firm mattress usually do well with our wool pillow. It is filled with wool pearls that give firmer support and hold their height, at about 17 cm. If you need more or less height, the adjustable alpaca pillow comes in Medium (16 cm) and High (18 cm), and you can add or remove fill from either.

PillowFillSizeFeelCare
100% NZ Wool PillowNew Zealand wool pearls50 x 75 cm, about 17 cm high, 1000 gMedium, with firmer supportSpot clean, air in the sun
Premium NZ Alpaca Adjustable PillowNew Zealand alpaca fleece pearls45 x 70 cm, Medium 16 cm or High 18 cmSoft; add or remove fill to set the heightDry clean, spot clean small marks

Back and stomach sleepers

Back sleepers on a firm mattress usually need a medium height to support the neck curve. Stomach sleepers still need a low pillow. See our guides to back sleeping and soft, low pillows.

NZ orders over $150 (after discounts) ship free, orders generally leave us within 5 working days and Aramex usually delivers within 7 days. Pillows cannot be returned unless faulty, for hygiene reasons, so call 09 622 1318 if you would like help choosing first.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a higher pillow with a firm mattress?

Usually, if you sleep on your side. Your shoulder sinks in less on a firm mattress, so the gap between your head and the bed is wider.

What pillow is best for a firm mattress?

One that fills the gap between your head and the mattress in your usual position. For side sleepers that often means a higher, firmer pillow such as wool pearls.

Should my pillow be firm if my mattress is firm?

Height matters more than firmness. Choose a pillow that holds the height you need through the night.

Match your pillow to your mattress, or call 09 622 1318 and we will help you choose.

About this guide

We are Kiwi Wool, a family-owned maker of wool and alpaca bedding. We make our wool pearl pillow and adjustable alpaca pillow, along with our duvet inners, in our own factory in Mangere, Auckland, where we have worked since 2002. The product details come from our own pillow specifications. This guide was last reviewed in November 2026. If you spot something that needs correcting, email info@kiwiwool.nz or call 09 622 1318.